Australia’s plan to recruit from Papua New Guinea for its Defence Force raises “major ethical concerns”, according to the Australia Defence Association, while another expert thinks it is broadly a good idea.
The two nations are set to begin negotiating a new defence treaty that is expected to see Papua New Guineans join the Australian Defence Force (ADF).
Australia Defence Association executive director Neil James believes “it’s an idiot idea” if there is no pathway to citizenship for Papua New Guineans who serve in the ADF
“You can’t expect other people to defend your country if you’re not willing to do it and until this scheme actually addresses this in any detail, we’re not going to know whether it’s an idiot idea or it’s something that might be workable in the long run.”
However, an expert associate at the Australian National University’s National Security College, Jennifer Parker, believes it is a good idea.
“Australia having a closer relationship with Papua New Guinea through that cross pollination of people going and working in each other’s defence forces, that’s incredibly positive.”
Parker said recruiting from the Pacific has been an ongoing conversation, but the exact nature of what the recruitment might look like is unknown, including whether there is a pathway to citizenship or if there would be a separate PNG unit within the ADF.
Extreme scenario
When asked whether it was ethical for people from PNG to fight Australia’s wars, Parker said that would be an extreme scenario.
“We’re not talking about conscripting people from other countries or anything like that. We’re talking about offering the opportunity for people, if they choose to join,” she said.
“There are many defence forces around the world where people choose, people who are born in other countries, choose to join.”
However, James disagrees.
“Whether they’re volunteers or whether they’re conscripted, you’re still expecting foreigners to defend your society and with no link to that society.”
Both Parker and James brought up concerns surrounding brain drain.
James said in Timor-Leste, in the early 2000s, many New Zealanders in the army infantry who were serving alongside Australia joined the Australian Army, attracted by the higher pay, which was not in the interest of New Zealand or Australia in the long run.
Care needed
“You’ve got to be real careful that you don’t ruin the Papua New Guinea Defence Force by making it too easy for Papua New Guineans to serve in the Australian Defence Force.”
Parker said the policy needed to be crafted very clearly in conjunction with Papua New Guinea to make sure it strengthened the two nations relationship, not undermined it.
Australia aims to grow the number of ADF uniformed personnel to 80,000 by 2040. However, it is not on track to meet that target.
Parker said she did not think Australia was trying to fill the shortfall.
“There are a couple of challenges in the recruitment issues for the Australian Defence Force.
“But I don’t think the scoping of recruiting people from Papua New Guinea and the Pacific Islands, if it indeed goes ahead, is about addressing recruitment for the Australian Defence Force.
“I think it’s about increasing closer security ties between Papua New Guinea, the Pacific Islands, and Australia.”
This article is republished under a community partnership agreement with RNZ.
This content originally appeared on Asia Pacific Report and was authored by APR editor.
The Advanced Strategic Capabilities Accelerator will work with industry to prove up and potentially acquire sovereign technologies that can protect against drone swarm attacks as part of its latest innovation mission. As Defence considers its options for a suite of Counter-Small Uncrewed Aerial Systems (CsUAS) capabilities, the accelerator has kicked off ‘Mission Syracuse’, a complementary…
Within hours of the news break about India’s Operation Sindoor targeting terrorist bases in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir on May 7, an 11-second video showing multiple red lights across the night sky went viral on social media. At first glance, the footage appears to show an air defense system firing at an aerial target.
A fortnight after a terrorist attack in Pahalgam had killed 26 people, Indian Armed Forces hit nine sites containing terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and PoK from where attacks against India had been planned and directed. The Union ministry of defence described the action as “focused, measured and non-escalatory in nature”, with no Pakistani military facilities having been targeted.
A Pakistani X handle, @Move111Forward, shared the clip in question with a caption in extremely derogatory language, which claimed that Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi had been given a befitting reply by Pakistan. In other words, he claimed the clip showed Pakistan’s response to Indian strikes. (Archive)
On YouTube, an account named Raza Joiya, shared the video clip claiming that it is the first strike from India.
Fact Check
After breaking the video into several key frames, we performed a reverse image search on a few of them, this led us to a post from April 10, 2025, on X by Maria Drutska. In the post, the user shared their concern over what they believed was an UFO spotted over Moscow, Russia.
We found another post on Facebook from April 10, 2025, by a Ukrainian media outlet Телекомпанія “Магнолія-ТВ” (Magnolia TV- broadcasting company). It shared a keyframe from the video with a caption that can be roughly translated as, “Meanwhile, in Russia – overnight, unidentified drone-helicopters attacked the Kaluga region and the Moscow suburbs. Specifically, Vnukovo Airport in Moscow and Kaluga Airport were temporarily closed under the “Carpet” protocol.”
Тим часом на росії – вночі невідомі дрони-гелікоптери атакували Калуську область та Підмосковʼє…
Зокрема аеропорти Внуково у Москві та Калузьский аеропорт закривались за планом «Килим».
Taking a cue from this, we performed a relevant keyword search that led us to several news reports from Russian news outlets. An article by Newsweek published on April 10, 2025, refers to the same video and states that Russian air defence fired at mysterious objects in the sky, sparking speculation. It adds that “conflicting accounts have emerged from Russia concerning the intended target of an overnight air defense operation in the Moscow region.”
While “state-run news agency RT reported Thursday that air defenses targeted “helicopter drones,” several Russian Telegram channels suggested that Russia’s air defenses may have mistakenly targeted one of their own military helicopters, the report said.
To sum up, the video clip in question is neither recent nor related to Operation Sindoor. The footage is from Russia. While some Russian media outlets claimed it showed Russian air defence targeting helicopter drones, Telegram channels suggested that Russia’s air defenses might have mistakenly targeted one of their own military helicopters.
Within hours of the news break about India’s Operation Sindoor targeting terrorist bases in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir on May 7, an 11-second video showing multiple red lights across the night sky went viral on social media. At first glance, the footage appears to show an air defense system firing at an aerial target.
A fortnight after a terrorist attack in Pahalgam had killed 26 people, Indian Armed Forces hit nine sites containing terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and PoK from where attacks against India had been planned and directed. The Union ministry of defence described the action as “focused, measured and non-escalatory in nature”, with no Pakistani military facilities having been targeted.
A Pakistani X handle, @Move111Forward, shared the clip in question with a caption in extremely derogatory language, which claimed that Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi had been given a befitting reply by Pakistan. In other words, he claimed the clip showed Pakistan’s response to Indian strikes. (Archive)
On YouTube, an account named Raza Joiya, shared the video clip claiming that it is the first strike from India.
Fact Check
After breaking the video into several key frames, we performed a reverse image search on a few of them, this led us to a post from April 10, 2025, on X by Maria Drutska. In the post, the user shared their concern over what they believed was an UFO spotted over Moscow, Russia.
We found another post on Facebook from April 10, 2025, by a Ukrainian media outlet Телекомпанія “Магнолія-ТВ” (Magnolia TV- broadcasting company). It shared a keyframe from the video with a caption that can be roughly translated as, “Meanwhile, in Russia – overnight, unidentified drone-helicopters attacked the Kaluga region and the Moscow suburbs. Specifically, Vnukovo Airport in Moscow and Kaluga Airport were temporarily closed under the “Carpet” protocol.”
Тим часом на росії – вночі невідомі дрони-гелікоптери атакували Калуську область та Підмосковʼє…
Зокрема аеропорти Внуково у Москві та Калузьский аеропорт закривались за планом «Килим».
Taking a cue from this, we performed a relevant keyword search that led us to several news reports from Russian news outlets. An article by Newsweek published on April 10, 2025, refers to the same video and states that Russian air defence fired at mysterious objects in the sky, sparking speculation. It adds that “conflicting accounts have emerged from Russia concerning the intended target of an overnight air defense operation in the Moscow region.”
While “state-run news agency RT reported Thursday that air defenses targeted “helicopter drones,” several Russian Telegram channels suggested that Russia’s air defenses may have mistakenly targeted one of their own military helicopters, the report said.
To sum up, the video clip in question is neither recent nor related to Operation Sindoor. The footage is from Russia. While some Russian media outlets claimed it showed Russian air defence targeting helicopter drones, Telegram channels suggested that Russia’s air defenses might have mistakenly targeted one of their own military helicopters.
In an election dominated by pressing issues like housing, the cost of living, energy transition, Medicare and jobs, it may seem counterintuitive to prioritise space. But if we are serious about securing Australia’s future prosperity, national security, and global relevance, investing in space is not just important – it is essential. Australia stands on a…
SpaceX, the rocket maker founded by tech billionaire Elon Musk, has struck its first direct contract with the Australian government to supply its popular Starlink satellite internet service to Defence. Defence joined the growing number of customers in regional and rural Australia to turn to Starlink for its fast internet speeds when it signed a…
Defence has contracted AWS and Microsoft to help with its migration and multi-cloud environment, inking fresh limited tender deals with the US hyperscalers worth more than $12 million. The cloud work comes after a significant shift in facilities last year when Defence migrated out of a Sydney data centre over concerns about Chinese ownership, and…
Defence has contracted AWS and Microsoft to help with its migration and multi-cloud environment, inking fresh limited tender deals with the US hyperscalers worth more than $12 million. The cloud work comes after a significant shift in facilities last year when Defence migrated out of a Sydney data centre over concerns about Chinese ownership, and…
A new Defence supercomputer almost a decade in the making is now up and running in Adelaide, delivering machine learning and AI capabilities to defence scientists. Defence declared the high-performance computing (HPC) system, dubbed Taingiwilta, “fully operational” on Friday, ending a long-running project led by Defence Science and Technology Group. Having recently achieved final operational…
The advanced technology pillar of the AUKUS agreement is going under the microscope in the UK, with a new parliamentary inquiry to probe whether there is “sufficient clarity” on how capabilities like AI and quantum are being developed. The UK’s inquiry will examine growing concerns about the scope, funding, objectives, and delivery of Pillar II, and…
South Australian space and AI firms, local universities and Defence’s research arm will partner to demonstrate an ambitious new sensor network after securing a $1.6 million collaboration grant. The grant is the largest of seven announced Wednesday from the Defence Innovation Partnership which funds South Australian research that could give Australian forces a technical edge….
Fleet Space Technologies says a sovereign satellite communications system for Australia’s military is still feasible, after delivering a low-Earth orbit satellite project to Defence. As Australia explores a militarised version of Starlink for its Defence satcom needs, the Adelaide-based nanosatellite startup has wrapped up work with Defence Space Command as part of an R&D program,…
US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has reaffirmed the Trump administration’s defence commitments to America’s Pacific territories of Guam and Northern Mariana Islands and that any attack on them would be an attack on the mainland.
Hegseth touched down in Guam from Hawai’i on Thursday as part of an Indo-Pacific tour, his first as Defence Secretary, in which he is seeking to shore up traditional alliances to counter China.
Geostrategic competition between the US and China in the Pacific has seen Guam and neighboring CNMI become increasingly significant in supporting American naval and air operations, especially in the event of a conflict over Taiwan or in the South China Sea.
Any attack on Guam and the Commonwealth Northern Marianas Islands would be met with “appropriate response,” Hegseth said during his brief visit, emphasising both territories were central to the US defence posture focused on containing China.
“We’re defending our homeland,” Hegseth said. “Guam and CNMI are vital parts of America, and I want to be very clear — to everyone in this room, to the cameras — any attack against these islands is an attack against the US.”
“We’re going to continue to stay committed to our presence here,” Hegseth said. “It’s important to emphasise: we are not seeking war with Communist China. But it is our job to ensure that we are ready.”
Key US strategic asset
Located closer to Beijing than Hawai’i, Guam serves as a key US strategic asset, known as the “tip of the spear,” with 10,000 military personnel, an air base for F-35 fighters and B-2 bombers, and home port for Virginia-class nuclear submarines.
The pledge from Hegseth comes as debate on Guam’s future as a US territory has intensified, with competing calls by some residents for full statehood and UN-mandated decolonisation, led by the Indigenous Chamorro people.
US Secretary of Defence Pete Hegseth (left) meets with Guam Governor Lou Leon Guerrero (far center) and CNMI Governor Arnold Palacios (far right) on his visit to the US Pacific territory on Thursday. Image: US Secretary of Defence
Defending Guam and CNMI, Hegseth said, aligns with President Donald Trump’s “goal to achieve peace through strength by putting America first”.
He delivered remarks at Andersen Air Force Base and took an aerial tour of the island before meeting with Lou Leon Guerrero and Arnold Palacios, governors of Guam and Northern Marianas, respectively.
Guerrero appealed to Hegseth about the “great impact” the US military buildup on Guam had had on the island’s residents.
“We welcome you, and we welcome the position and the posture that President Trump has,” Guerrero told Hegseth, during opening statements before their closed-door meeting.
“We are the centre of gravity here. We are the second island chain of defence,” she said. “We want to be a partner in the readiness effort but national security cannot happen without human health security.”
Funding for hospital
Guerrero sought funding for a new hospital, estimated to cost US$600 million.
“Our island needs a regional hospital capable of handling mass casualties — whether from conflict or natural disasters,” she told Hegseth.
“We are working very closely in partnership with the military, and one of our asks is to be a partner in the financing of that hospital.”
Afterwards Guerrero told reporters she did not have time to discuss the housing crisis caused by the US military buildup.
Earlier this month, Guerrero warned in her “state of the island” address of US neglect of Guam’s 160,000 residents, where one-in-five are estimated to live below the poverty line.
“Let us be clear about this: Guam cannot be the linchpin of American security in the Asian-Pacific if nearly 14,000 of our residents are without shelter, because housing aid to Guam is cut, or if 36,000 of our people lose access to Medicaid and Medicare coverage keeping them healthy, alive and out of poverty,” Guerrero said.
At the end of his visit to Guam, Hegseth announced in a statement he had also reached an “understanding” with President Wesley Simina of the Federated States of Micronesia to begin planning and construction of US$400 million in military infrastructure projects in the State of Yap.
Territorial background
Simina’s office would not confirm to BenarNews he had met with Hegseth in Guam, saying only he was “off island.”
As a territory, Guam residents are American citizens but they cannot vote for the US president and their lone delegate to the Congress has no voting power.
The US acquired Guam in 1898 after winning the Spanish-American War, and CNMI from Japan in 1945 after its defeat in the Second World War. Both remain unincorporated territories to this day.
The Defence Department holds about 25 percent of Guam’s land and is preparing to spend billions to upgrade the island’s military infrastructure as another 5000 American marines relocate from Japan’s Okinawa islands.
On Tuesday, Hegseth was in Hawai’i meeting officials of the US Indo-Pacific Command. Speaking with the media in Honolulu, he said his Asia-Pacific visit was to show strength to allies and “reestablish deterrence.”
Hegseth’s week-long tour comes against a backdrop of growing Chinese assertiveness. Its coast guard vessels have recently encroached into the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone in the South China Sea and around the Japanese-controlled Senkaku Islands in the East China Sea.
His visit will be closely watched in the Pacific for signs of the Trump administration’s commitment to traditional allies following a rift between Washington and Europe that has tested the transatlantic alliance.
The trip also threatens to be overshadowed by the fallout from revelations that he and other national security officials discussed attack plans against Yemen’s Houthis on the messaging app Signal with a journalist present.
Flagrant violation
Critics are calling it a flagrant violation of information security protocols.
During his first term, Trump revived Washington’s engagements in the Pacific island region after long years of neglect paved the way for China’s initiatives.
He hosted leaders of the US freely associated states of Palau, Marshall Islands and Federated States of Micronesia at the White House in 2019.
The Biden administration followed through, doubling the engagement with an increased presence and complementing the military buildup with economic assistance that sought to outdo China’s Belt and Road Initiative.
The new Trump administration, however, cut the cord, dismantling the US Agency for International Development (USAID), and along with it, the millions of dollars pledged to Pacific island nations.
The abolition of about 80 percent of USAID programmes sent mixed signals to the island nations and security experts have warned that China would fill the void it has created.
From Guam, Hegseth has travelled to Philippines and Japan, where he will participate in a ceremony commemorating the 80th anniversary of the Battle of Iwo Jima and will later meet with Japanese leaders and US military forces.
Republished from BenarNews with permission. Stefan Armbruster in Brisbane contributed to this story.
This content originally appeared on Asia Pacific Report and was authored by Asia Pacific.
Australia will follow the United States and set up a new office dedicated to selling sovereign defence capabilities, including high-tech combat drones and radar technology, to international security partners. The Australian Defence Strategic Sales Office (ADSSO), announced as the government entered caretaker mode on Friday, will act as a central coordination platform with Defence to…
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese says radar technology that Canada has agreed to purchase from Australia is “world-leading” and will help forge closer ties between the two countries amid growing trade uncertainty. Canada announced the $6.6 billion partnership with Australia on Wednesday (AEDT time), setting up a program of work to deliver a new early warning…
Defence’s second attempt at cutover to the “backbone” of its new multi-billion dollar SAP enterprise resource planning system will get underway before the end of this month, a full six weeks before go-live. As IBM system integration costs pass $500 million, Defence has set May 12 as the new deadline for the main release of…
US defence and aerospace giant Lockheed Martin tipped more than $300 million into its bid for Defence’s military-grade satellite communications system before it was jettisoned, new documents show. Defence abandoned Phase One of the project known as JP9102 in November last year, replacing plans for a geo-stationary satellite with an alternative approach that relies on…
A prototype high energy laser system being developed for the Australian Defence Force has been successfully demonstrated for the first time in Adelaide by multinational defence technology company QinetiQ. The company announced the milestone on the joint project with Defence Science and Technology Group (DSTG) this week, bringing Australia closer to sovereign directed energy defensive…
Defence is exploring the possibility of using SpaceX’s Starshield for military-grade satellite communications after axing its first run at a “sovereign-controlled” constellation project last year. Military officials last week confirmed that discussions into using low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellites purpose-built for the United States as an alternative to geo-stationary satellites are underway, as the force looks…
Defence took back control of its troubled data consolidation overhaul from KPMG before it reached minimum viable capability late last year after identifying “deficiencies” with the contracted work, Senate Estimates has heard. The consulting giant’s technology arm corrected the shortcoming after a period of “hypercare”, before exiting the ambitious program altogether, Defence chief information officer…
Australia will buy as many as 14 muti-mission phased array radars from CEA Technologies, the defence tech manufacturer acquired by the federal governments in 2023. Defence minister Richard Marles announced the $272 million purchase from the Canberra-based firm on Wednesday, with the first radars to be delivered to the Australian Army from 2027. It is…
Defence has inked its biggest cloud deal with Amazon Web Services to build a new mystery platform on the American hyperscaler’s infrastructure. The department declined to say exactly what its new platform will be used for, despite the $16.3 million contract being its biggest for cloud services with the market leader and coming through a…
Local defence companies have chalked up more than $25 million in licence-free exports to the United States and United Kingdom in less than six months under Australia’s new export control regime. That’s according to Defence minister Richard Marles, who spruiked the apparent milestone just hours after a first meeting with US Defence secretary Pete Hegseth…
Australia’s $2 billion Top Secret cloud is sorely needed by defence and intelligence agencies that have fallen years behind the private sector, allies and some adversaries. But the government’s decision to go with a single market leading US vendor over local providers while extolling sovereignty has raised difficult questions. As the dust settles on last…
Australia’s national science agency will help modernise the Royal Australian Navy’s electronic warfare capabilities under an initial $21 million contract, joining the multi-decade program currently led by multinational defence prime Raytheon. The $726 million Modernisation of Maritime Electronic Warfare (MMEW) Project aims to deliver a variety of new and enhanced electro-optical, infrared and ultraviolet capabilities…
From an inconspicuous former wool store in inner city Sydney, one of Australia’s defence technology pioneers is working to tackle the escalating security threat presented by unmanned drones. The new home of the counter-drone device-maker DroneShield is a game changer for the fast-growing company, which listed on the ASX back in 2016 and has a…
A Defence TAFE Centre of Excellence will be set up in Western Australia with the help of the federal government to deliver industry training opportunities in support of AUKUS. The centre, announced alongside the state’s Defence and Defence Industry Strategy 2025 on Wednesday, will offer training across the five defence domains of land, air, maritime,…
The federal government has detailed plans for an additional $262.4 million to be spent supporting domestic defence industry participation in the nuclear submarine supply chain being developed as part of the AUKUS arrangements. Defence Industry minister Pat Conroy said the additional funding would be used for submarine-specific rounds of the Defence Industry Development Grants Program,…
The new head of the Australian Cyber Security Centre is Stephanie Crowe, who replaces Abigail Bradshaw following her promotion to director-general of the Australian Signals Directorate. Ms Crowe has spent more than 15 years at the Australian Signals Directorate (ASD), across signals intelligence and cybersecurity. Her most recent role was as the head of the…
Defence has extended its engagement with Accenture for aircraft maintenance software for another three years, handing the tech services giant another $28 million for work it has led for almost two decades. Accenture beat out a handful of other bids to keep responsibility for managing the Computer Aided Maintenance Management (CAMM2) system it delivered for…