Category: Watchdog

  • Andrei Afanasyev, a freelance correspondent for RFE/RL’s Russian Service, has been detained as he traveled to cover anti-government protests in Russia’s Far East city of Blagoveshchensk.

    The journalist was stopped by traffic police on January 31 ahead of nationwide protests against the jailing of prominent activist and Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny.

    Afansyev, who was in possession of a press pass and proof that he was on assignment, was taken to a local police station.

    On January 24, when an estimated 4,000 people were arrested for participating in anti-government demonstrations across the country, Afansyev was briefly detained and members of his family were subsequently questioned about his activities.

    Several RFE/RL freelancers were approached by police in the lead-up to demonstrations in 142 cities planned for January 31.

    On the day itself, the independent monitor OVD-Info reported that multiple journalists were detained around the country ahead of the scheduled rallies.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • The United Nations has urged Iran to halt the “imminent” execution of a member of the Baluch ethnic minority as it rebuked Tehran for a number of recent hangings, including members of the country’s ethnic minorities.

    “We urge the authorities to halt the execution of Javid Dehghan, to review his and other death penalty cases in line with human rights law,” the Geneva-based Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) said on Twitter on January 29.

    “We strongly condemn the series of executions — at least 28 — since mid-December, including of people from minority groups,” the UN added.

    The UN said Dehghan had been sentenced to death in 2017 for “taking up arms to take lives or property and to create fear.”

    Amnesty International said on January 28 that Dehghan, 31, is scheduled to be executed on January 31.

    The London-based rights group said Dehghan was sentenced to death in connection with his alleged membership in the extremist group Jaish Al-Adl (Army of Justice) and his alleged role in an ambush that killed two members of Iran’ Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps.

    Jaish Al-Adl has reportedly carried out several high-profile bombings and abductions in Iran in recent years.

    Amnesty said his trial was “grossly unfair” with the court relying on “torture-tainted confessions” and ignoring abuses committed during the investigation.

    “Amnesty International urges the Iranian authorities not to compound the shocking catalogue of human rights violations already committed against Javid Dehghan by carrying out his execution,” the rights group said.

    Activists outside Iran have in past weeks expressed concern over the numbers of ethnic Baluch being executed or facing capital punishment in Iran.

    Abdollah Aref, the director of the Europe-based Campaign of Baluch Activists, told the BBC earlier this week that in the past two months his group has documented the execution of 16 members of the Baluch minority.

    The UN said Iran has launched a crackdown on minorities since mid-December.

    “This has included a series of executions of members of ethnic and religious minority groups — in particular Kurdish, Ahwazi Arab, and Baluch communities,” OHCHR spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani said.

    Iran is one of the world’s leading executioners.

    With reporting by AFP

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Police are searching the apartment of jailed Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny, according to Ivan Zhdanov, the director of the opposition politician’s Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK).

    “The apartment of Aleksei Navalny is being searched. There are lots of “heavies” [security officers] wearing masks. They started to break down the door. Oleg Navalny [Aleksei’s brother] is in the apartment. We do not know why or on what basis they are conducting the search,” Zhdanov said in a tweet.

    Navalny was arrested on January 17 upon returning to Russia from Germany, where he had been recovering from a near-fatal poisoning by a military-grade nerve agent in August that he accuses Putin of ordering.

    A court later extended his detention for 30 days to allow for a different court to decide in early February on whether to convert into real prison time the suspended 3 1/2 year sentence that Navalny served in an embezzlement case, which is widely considered trumped up and politically motivated.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Police are searching the apartment of jailed Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny, according to Ivan Zhdanov, the director of the opposition politician’s Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK).

    “The apartment of Aleksei Navalny is being searched. There are lots of “heavies” [security officers] wearing masks. They started to break down the door. Oleg Navalny [Aleksei’s brother] is in the apartment. We do not know why or on what basis they are conducting the search,” Zhdanov said in a tweet.

    Navalny was arrested on January 17 upon returning to Russia from Germany, where he had been recovering from a near-fatal poisoning by a military-grade nerve agent in August that he accuses Putin of ordering.

    A court later extended his detention for 30 days to allow for a different court to decide in early February on whether to convert into real prison time the suspended 3 1/2 year sentence that Navalny served in an embezzlement case, which is widely considered trumped up and politically motivated.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • BISHKEK — In the space of a single month, three Kyrgyz women from different walks of life killed themselves in the northeastern Issyk-Kul region in separate cases linked to domestic violence.

    Among them was Aruuzat, a 33-year-old schoolteacher from the city of Karakol who died in the hospital on December 29 after consuming a fatal dose of vinegar.

    In a WhatsApp message sent from her deathbed, Aruuzat told her colleagues that she had decided to end her life because her family wanted her to reconcile with her abusive husband despite being beaten by him.

    Aruuzat, a mother of three, also sent photos of what she said was her bruised body after the latest abuse at the hands of her spouse.

    They don’t get any support from their relatives, and they also fear disgrace in society. Therefore, most of them go back to their abusive husbands in the end.”

    Her colleagues told RFE/RL they had been aware of her situation but that she didn’t want them to report her husband to the police.

    “She had told us about the beatings. She said if she ran away, her husband would find her using the phone geolocation and torture her even more,” Aruuzat’s colleague and friend, Nazira, told RFE/RL. “She was terrified of her husband.”

    It was only after Aruuzat’s death that her colleagues reported to police about the domestic abuse she had suffered. Despite that, Aruuzat’s mother, siblings, and other relatives still remain silent on the subject.

    It’s a long-standing tradition for abuse to be quietly accepted in Kyrgyzstan — a country where divorce is shunned and women are encouraged to keep their marriages intact at almost any cost.

    Impunity often remains a norm for domestic violence in the Central Asian country, where some women — like Aruuzat — end up paying the ultimate price.

    But the Kyrgyz parliament is finally taking a decisive step to prevent families from putting pressure on the victims of domestic violence and to reconcile with their abusive spouses.

    In an unprecedented move, the parliament passed a bill that bans such reconciliation if one of the parties in the marriage subjects his or her spouse to physical or mental abuse.

    The bill also calls for harsher punishments for domestic violence.

    Lawmaker Ishak Pirmatov, who initiated the bill: “Criminal behavior will continue if there is no punishment.” (file photo)

    Lawmaker Ishak Pirmatov, who initiated the bill: “Criminal behavior will continue if there is no punishment.” (file photo)

    Initiated by lawmaker Ishak Pirmatov, the amendments to the law on domestic violence were approved by parliament on the second reading on January 20.

    Domestic violence has always been a hot topic in Kyrgyzstan, where police record thousands of cases every year. Thousands of other incidents of abuse go unreported.

    In 2020, Kyrgyz police recorded 9,025 cases of domestic violence, a 65 percent rise compared to previous years.

    But only about 940 of the cases were sent to courts, authorities say. In all other cases, the victims — the majority of them women — withdrew their complaints, telling police they had changed their minds.

    ‘Crime Shouldn’t Go Unpunished’

    “There are many cases in which the victim opts for reconciliation under the pressure of the family. As a result, the case doesn’t go to court, while the victim still remains unprotected,” lawmaker Natalia Nikitenko said during the parliamentary debate.

    “Now, the bill introduces new standards that prohibit the reconciliation of the parties if it puts one of the parties in harm’s way, or in cases in which one of the parties has already been subjected to violence,” Nikitenko said.

    Lawmaker Natalia Nikitenko: “It will no longer be possible to hide [the crime] in the name of reconciliation.” (file photo)

    Lawmaker Natalia Nikitenko: “It will no longer be possible to hide [the crime] in the name of reconciliation.” (file photo)

    Current law states that if the victim withdraws a complaint, the police can drop the case. Under the new bill, however, police are required to launch a probe into suspected domestic violence even if the alleged victim takes back his or her initial complaint.

    According to Nikitenko, “It will no longer be possible to hide [the crime] in the name of reconciliation.”

    Some lawmakers spoke against the bill, arguing that marriage is a complex and delicate issue and that the best option for all sides is to save the union.

    “Anything can happen in a family,” said lawmaker Kamchybek Zholdoshbaev, who advocated reconciliation at all costs. “Maybe we need to look for other solutions? For example, the [couple’s] elders should be consulted, or a representative of the local councils should get involved.”

    But parliamentarian Pirmatov insisted the victims cannot be protected if the perpetrators know they can get away with a crime under the pretext of reconciliation.

    “Criminal behavior will continue if there is no punishment,” Pirmatov said.

    The bill must pass a third reading and be signed by President Sadyr Japarov for the bill to become law.

    Helping The Victims Isn’t Always Easy

    Just days after Aruuzat’s death in Karakol, another woman’s life was cut short by domestic violence in the nearby Tyup district.

    Issyk-Kul regional police confirmed that 40-year-old housewife Gulmairam Taktasheva was strangled to death by her husband at home in the village of Dolon on January 9.

    Gulmairam Taktasheva

    Gulmairam Taktasheva

    “Her husband, Aibek, had been drinking a lot lately,” Taktasheva’s sister told RFE/RL. “When Gulmairam got upset and moved to our parents’ home, Aibek begged her to come back. They reconciled, but soon after he killed her.”

    Taktasheva’s husband subsequently committed suicide, leaving the couple’s four children without parents.

    On January 12, another woman in Karakol killed herself amid allegations of domestic abuse. The 29-year-old mother of three worked at a local television station. Police said they were unable to open a criminal probe as there were no witnesses, no reports of a crime, and no complaints.

    Women’s rights advocates in Kyrgyzstan have welcomed the latest legislation, but they say more is needed to protect domestic violence victims. They are urging the government to set up special crisis centers where abuse victims can seek help with counseling and rehabilitation to recover from the abuse and rebuild their lives. Some of the victims are in desperate need of shelter and employment.

    There are only 17 crisis centers for women in a country of some 6.5 million people.

    In reality, helping the victims is not always as straightforward as it might seem, said Marina Lichanyu, the coordinator of Karakol’s Center for Rehabilitation and Support, who has extensive experience working with domestic violence victims.

    “About 80 percent of the women who approached our center for help don’t have adequate education,” Lichanyu told RFE/RL. “Most of them were married young or ended up in marriage through the bride-kidnapping tradition.”

    “It’s difficult to find them jobs and create favorable conditions in which they could independently support themselves and raise their children. They don’t get any support from their relatives, and they also fear disgrace in society. Therefore, most of them go back to their abusive husbands in the end,” she added.

    There have also been several dozen cases of men reporting abuse and cruel treatment at the hands of their wives.

    Kyrgyz authorities say they are committed to helping the victims. This week, the government launched a hotline — free phone line 117 — for victims of domestic abuse to report a crime and seek help.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Reporters Without Borders (RSF) is calling on the European Union to impose further sanctions on Russian officials after “more than 50 journalists were arbitrarily detained” during nationwide anti-government protests last weekend.

    The Paris-based media-freedom watchdog made the call on January 26, three days after media covering rallies in support of jailed Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny were subjected to an “unusually extensive and heavy-handed” crackdown to “prevent them from showing the scale of support for a government opponent.”

    “The police deliberately targeted certain media, going so far as to enter a private apartment in order to cut off a video feed of the demonstrations, and in a sign of the totally disproportionate nature of the crackdown, even clearly-identified reporters wearing ‘press’ vests or armbands were held for several hours,” Jeanne Cavelier, the head of RSF’s Eastern Europe and Central Asia desk, said in a statement.

    Cavelier called on the Russian authorities to end this “blatant obstruction of the freedom to inform.” He also urged the OSCE representative on freedom of the media, Teresa Ribeiro, to condemn the “violence and arbitrary arrests” and the EU to adopt “new sanctions against Russian officials.”

    Navalny was detained earlier this month upon returning to Russia from Germany, where he had been recovering from a near-fatal poisoning by a military-grade nerve agent in August he accuses President Vladimir Putin of ordering.

    A court is expected to decide on February 2 whether to convert into prison time a suspended sentence in a case that is widely considered trumped up and politically motivated.

    Meeting in Brussels on January 25, EU foreign ministers agreed to wait to see if Navalny is released before deciding to impose fresh sanctions.

    The EU’s foreign-policy chief, Josep Borrell, said he would go to Moscow next week to urge the authorities to free protesters and Navalny. EU leaders could discuss further action against Russia at a planned summit on March 25-26, he said.

    Russia has rebuffed the global outrage and a chorus of international calls calling for Navalny’s release.

    In its statement, RSF said the “extraordinary figure” of more than 50 detentions of reporters, some of whom were “subjected to police violence,” is based on data compiled by the independent political watchdog OVD-Info, the Russian Journalists and Media Workers Union, and information gathered directly by the watchdog.

    It cited the case of the independent TV channel Dozhd, which it said was “censored in mid-transmission when police cut the power supply to a Moscow apartment from which its crew was broadcasting.”

    Dozhd reporter Aleksei Korostelev and cameraman Sergei Novikov were then detained “on the pretext of verifying their identity.”

    Also in Moscow, riot police hit a reporter for the independent triweekly Novaya gazeta, Elizaveta Kirpanova, with their batons “for several minutes,” dealing some blows to her head, although she was “clearly identifiable by her ‘press’ vest and badge,” according to RSF.

    The group noted that police had already tried to intimidate journalists and media outlets in the run-up to the unsanctioned demonstrations across Russia, which attracted tens of thousands of people and saw more than 3,700 people detained, according to OVD-Info.

    Human Rights Watch (HRW) has said “extreme” police brutality and “mass” arbitrary detentions during the protests are further evidence of “how low human rights standards have plummeted” in the country.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A Belarusian lawyer who works for jailed Russian opposition politician Aleksei Navalny’s Anti-Corruption Foundation says he was handcuffed and forced into a car with a sack over his head before being driven 10 hours to the border by plainclothes police and handed over to Belarusian authorities.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • If it wasn’t obvious from the heavy police presence and official warnings how the Kremlin would respond to anti-government protests across Russia, the sound of an OMON officer’s swift kick to Margarita Yudina’s stomach and her pained screams as her head hit the pavement helped provide clarity.

    VIDEO: WARNING VIOLENT CONTENT
    https://www.currenttime.tv/a/margarita-yudina/31066205.html

    The violence employed by Russian security forces against the 54-year-old St. Petersburg resident was far from an isolated incident — thousands of protesters were rounded up and taken into custody, and there were scores of images showing police taking a heavy-handed approach to tamp down the largest anti-government protests in Russia in years.

    But none captured the moment like the short clip showing Yudina stepping in the path of three riot police as they led a young protester away in central St. Petersburg, one of many cities nationwide where Russians had risked assembling in groups to protest the jailing of opposition politician and staunch Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny.

    “Why did you grab him?” Yudina asked as she stepped into Nevsky Prospect, the city’s main thoroughfare, with the OMON officers in full riot gear several meters away. “Get out of the way!” came the reply, with one emphasizing the point in stride with a boot to her stomach.

    The force of blow caused Yudina to double over and fly backward, striking her head on the pavement and reportedly leaving her unconscious and in intensive care to treat a skull injury.

    Russian officials were quick to go into crisis-management mode as they attempted to touch up the bad image left by the video as it spread quickly on the Internet.

    The local Interior Ministry branch promised an investigation into the incident, while state-friendly media outlets were flooded with audio published by the Telegram channel Mash of a local police official apologizing to Yudina during a visit to her hospital room. https://t.me/breakingmash/2314

    “These are not our methods; this is not our system!” Colonel Sergei Muzika, head of the ministry branch’s department for protecting public order, can be heard saying. “We stand guard over law and order.”

    The further aftermath of the incident also caused controversy, with government critics voicing skepticism about the narrative of apology and forgiveness that played out in reports from media organizations close to the state.

    Yudina reportedly accepted Muzika’s apology, and Kremlin-friendly REN TV showed footage in which she appeared to be pleased with the flowers brought to her hospital room on January 24, reportedly by the unidentified officer who took responsibility for kicking her.

    Explaining that he was suffering from the effects of being tear-gassed and a fogged-up helmet visor, the masked officer is seen in REN-TV footage saying that he “did not see what was happening” and that when he found out what had happened to her he took it as a “personal tragedy.” https://ren.tv/news/v-rossii/795206-politseiskii-izvinilsia-pered-postradavshei-na-aktsii-v-peterburge-za-udar

    Yudina, who has since been transferred to another facility, is shown commenting on the chrysanthemums and telling the officer not to worry.

    The St. Petersburg news agency Fontanka later cited her as saying that she forgave the officer — whose visor is partially raised in the video footage of him kicking her — because she was an Orthodox Christian and that “I understand that our young people are in a difficult situation.”
    https://www.fontanka.ru/2021/01/24/69721911/

    Some pro-Kremlin commenters were touched by the apologetic tone taken by the authorities, with one suggesting on Telegram that this was “commendable” and suggesting that Yudina had essentially rushed into the path of a tank. https://t.me/kononenkome/29423

    But observers both inside and outside Russia were incredulous.

    Dmitry Aleshkovsky, co-founder of the media organization Takiye Dela, expressed bewilderment that the use of violence could be so easily forgiven with an apology.

    “What, so this was possible?” he wrote on Twitter, alluding to protesters who were jailed on what they said were fabricated charges of violence against police at an anti-government demonstration on the eve of Vladimir Putin’s inauguration to a third presidential term in 2012 and rallies related to Moscow elections in 2019.

    “The prisoners of Bolotnaya and those who received sentences for the Moscow Case, should they just ask forgiveness and give flowers to the riot police?”
    https://twitter.com/aleshru/status/1353376699849830400

    Despite obvious evidence to the contrary and media estimates that more than 100,000 people protested nationwide, state and state-friendly media have pushed the Kremlin narrative that the rallies on January 23 drew minimal crowds,

    In Moscow, city officials claimed that just 4,000 people took to the streets in support of Navalny — the Kremlin critic who was arrested upon his return to Russia on January 17 after receiving treatment abroad for a near-deadly poisoning in Siberia that he blames on the Federal Security Service and Putin himself — while Reuters reported its own tally of about 40,000. Nationwide, the OVD-Info group, which tracks police actions, reported that more than 3,700 people were detained for participating in the banned mass demonstrations.
    https://ovdinfo.org/

    The level of violence was high, with videos showing police beating protesters with truncheons and some demonstrators pelting police with snowballs and in some cases fighting with officers.

    The heavy-handed response to the protests – which were unsanctioned because rallies of more than one person are not allowed in Russia without official permission — have drawn condemnation from the United States and other Western countries.

    Nongovernmental organizations, too, were sharply critical of Russia’s actions, with some suggesting they could further stoke anti-government sentiment.

    “Ultimately this repression of basic human rights only galvanizes people and deepens their grievances,” Damelya Aitkhozhina, Russia researcher at the New York-based Human Rights Watch said on January 25. https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/01/25/russia-police-detain-thousands-pro-navalny-protests

    And Kremlin critics within Russia also suggested that events had played out as planned.

    “It is clear that the government wanted violence, the government provoked violence, from my point of view, and the government is obviously preparing a repressive response for the near future,” opposition politician and political scientist Leonid Gozman told Current Time in a video interview on January 24. https://www.currenttime.tv/a/gozman/31066541.htm

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • If it wasn’t obvious from the heavy police presence and official warnings how the Kremlin would respond to anti-government protests across Russia, the sound of an OMON officer’s swift kick to Margarita Yudina’s stomach and her pained screams as her head hit the pavement helped provide clarity.

    The violence employed by Russian security forces against the 54-year-old St. Petersburg resident was far from an isolated incident — thousands of protesters were rounded up and taken into custody, and there were scores of images showing police taking a heavy-handed approach to tamp down the largest anti-government protests in Russia in years.

    But none captured the moment like the short clip showing Yudina stepping in the path of three riot police as they led a young protester away in central St. Petersburg, one of many cities nationwide where Russians had risked assembling in groups to protest the jailing of opposition politician and staunch Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny.

    WARNING: Viewers May Find The Images In This Video Distressing

    “Why did you grab him?” Yudina asked as she stepped into Nevsky Prospect, the city’s main thoroughfare, with the OMON officers in full riot gear several meters away. “Get out of the way!” came the reply, with one emphasizing the point in stride with a boot to her stomach.

    The force of blow caused Yudina to double over and fly backward, striking her head on the pavement and reportedly leaving her unconscious and in intensive care to treat a skull injury.

    Russian officials were quick to go into crisis-management mode as they attempted to touch up the bad image left by the video as it spread quickly on the Internet.

    The local Interior Ministry branch promised an investigation into the incident, while state-friendly media outlets were flooded with audio published by the Telegram channel Mash of a local police official apologizing to Yudina during a visit to her hospital room.

    “These are not our methods; this is not our system!” Colonel Sergei Muzika, head of the ministry branch’s department for protecting public order, can be heard saying. “We stand guard over law and order.”

    The further aftermath of the incident also caused controversy, with government critics voicing skepticism about the narrative of apology and forgiveness that played out in reports from media organizations close to the state.

    Yudina reportedly accepted Muzika’s apology, and Kremlin-friendly REN TV showed footage in which she appeared to be pleased with the flowers brought to her hospital room on January 24, reportedly by the unidentified officer who took responsibility for kicking her.

    Explaining that he was suffering from the effects of being tear-gassed and a fogged-up helmet visor, the masked officer is seen in REN-TV footage saying that he “did not see what was happening” and that when he found out what had happened to her he took it as a “personal tragedy.”

    Yudina, who has since been transferred to another facility, is shown commenting on the chrysanthemums and telling the officer not to worry.

    Incredulous Observers

    The St. Petersburg news agency Fontanka later cited her as saying that she forgave the officer — whose visor is partially raised in the video footage of him kicking her — because she was an Orthodox Christian and that “I understand that our young people are in a difficult situation.”

    Some pro-Kremlin commenters were touched by the apologetic tone taken by the authorities, with one suggesting on Telegram that this was “commendable” and suggesting that Yudina had essentially rushed into the path of a tank.

    But observers both inside and outside Russia were incredulous.

    Dmitry Aleshkovsky, co-founder of the media organization Takiye Dela, expressed bewilderment that the use of violence could be so easily forgiven with an apology.

    “What, so this was possible?” he wrote on Twitter, alluding to protesters who were jailed on what they said were fabricated charges of violence against police at an anti-government demonstration on the eve of Vladimir Putin’s inauguration to a third presidential term in 2012 and rallies related to Moscow elections in 2019.

    “The prisoners of Bolotnaya and those who received sentences for the Moscow Case, should they just ask forgiveness and give flowers to the riot police?”

    Despite obvious evidence to the contrary and media estimates that more than 100,000 people protested nationwide, state and state-friendly media have pushed the Kremlin narrative that the rallies on January 23 drew minimal crowds.

    ‘The Government Wanted Violence’

    In Moscow, city officials claimed that just 4,000 people took to the streets in support of Navalny — the Kremlin critic who was arrested upon his return to Russia on January 17 after receiving treatment abroad for a near-deadly poisoning in Siberia that he blames on the Federal Security Service and Putin himself — while Reuters reported its own tally of about 40,000. Nationwide, the OVD-Info group, which tracks police actions, reported that more than 3,700 people were detained for participating in the banned mass demonstrations.

    The level of violence was high, with videos showing police beating protesters with truncheons and some demonstrators pelting police with snowballs and in some cases fighting with officers.

    The heavy-handed response to the protests – which were unsanctioned because rallies of more than one person are not allowed in Russia without official permission — have drawn condemnation from the United States and other Western countries.

    Nongovernmental organizations, too, were sharply critical of Russia’s actions, with some suggesting they could further stoke anti-government sentiment.

    “Ultimately this repression of basic human rights only galvanizes people and deepens their grievances,” Damelya Aitkhozhina, Russia researcher at the New York-based Human Rights Watch said on January 25.

    And Kremlin critics within Russia also suggested that events had played out as planned.

    “It is clear that the government wanted violence, the government provoked violence, from my point of view, and the government is obviously preparing a repressive response for the near future,” opposition politician and political scientist Leonid Gozman told Current Time in a video interview on January 24.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • The operations at two human rights organizations in Kazakhstan have been suspended and they may face closure amid a crackdown on rights groups in the Central Asian state.

    The head of the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule Of Law (KMBPCh), Yevgeny Zhovtis, told RFE/RL that tax officials in Almaty ruled on January 25 to suspend the group’s activities for three months and ordered it to pay 2 million tenges ($4,700) in fines, citing “financial irregularities.”

    According to Zhovtis, the officials did not give a detailed explanation for the action.

    “We will appeal the decision in court, but if the decision is politically motivated there is not much hope for us,” Zhovtis said.

    Amangeldy Shormanbekov, chief of another group, the International Rights Initiative, told RFE/RL that tax authorities in Almaty had also suspended his organization’s activities for three months and ordered it to pay the same fine as KMBPCh.

    “This is a political order, persecution. It looks like the authorities do not want us to have links with the UN, OSCE, the European Union member states. They want to keep our mouths’ shut so that nobody in the country can talk to international structures,” Shormanbekov said, adding that his organization faced a full shutdown if the decision is upheld in court.

    The two groups are the latest of more than a dozen of nongovernmental organizations that have faced inspections by tax authorities across the country since November 2019.

    Rights groups say the inspections and restrictive decisions have intensified in recent weeks.

    RFE/RL has officially asked tax authorities to explain the situation but has yet to receive an answer.

    The organizations facing pressure are involved in monitoring elections, defending human and civil rights, and promoting the rule of law.

    Last week, Human Rights Watch said in a statement that alleged financial-reporting violations cast “serious doubt” that Kazakhstan’s leadership is working on improving its human rights record.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Ihar Losik, a popular Belarusian blogger, says he has ended a hunger strike he began more than two months ago to protest charges that he helped organize riots over a disputed presidential election that has triggered a wave of protests — and a harsh crackdown by the officials under Alyaksandr Lukashenka, the authoritarian leader who has held power since 1994.

    “I have decided to end my hunger strike. Why have I done so? I did it on my own volition…. I was simply moved by the unbelievable wave of solidarity,” he said in a statement via his lawyer on January 25.

    “Also, because of the hundreds and thousands of requests by Belarusians for me to end it, so that we can await our common victory in a healthy state. I also know that many have begun hunger strikes in solidarity with me. I cannot take on the weight of that responsibility. I don’t want people to suffer for my conscious decisions.”

    Losik was arrested on June 25 and accused of using his popular Telegram channel to “prepare to disrupt public order” ahead of an August 9 presidential election that Lukashenka claimed he won by a landslide amid allegations of widespread fraud.

    Since then, Belarus has witnessed nearly daily demonstrations whose size and scope are unparalleled in the country’s post-Soviet history.

    While awaiting his trial, the 28-year-old was sent to the Akrestsina detention center in Minsk, which Amnesty International has described as “synonymous with torture.”

    Former detainees have spoken of brutal beatings by guards at Akrestsina and other jails in Belarus. If convicted, Losik faces a possible three-year prison term.

    Then, on December 15, Losik, a consultant for RFE/RL on new-media technologies, was slapped with fresh charges that could result in an eight-year prison term if he is convicted. In protest, Losik, who has been recognized as a political prisoner by rights activists, launched his hunger strike.

    On January 15, his wife, Darya Losik, told Current Time that her husband’s health was deteriorating and that medical attention was minimal.

    Losik’s statement on January 25 did not give details on his current health status.

    Western governments have refused to acknowledge Lukashenka as the winner of the vote, and imposed sanctions on him and his allies, citing election rigging and the police crackdown.

    Lukashenka has refused to step down and says he will not negotiate with the opposition.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Human Rights Watch (HRW) says “extreme” police brutality and “mass” arbitrary detentions during weekend protests across Russia are further evidence of “how low human rights standards have plummeted” in the country.

    “Ultimately this repression of basic human rights only galvanizes people and deepens their [protesters’] grievances,” Damelya Aitkhozhina, the Russia researcher at the New York-based watchdog, said in a statement on January 25, two days after thousands of Russians were detained during protests against the arrest of Kremlin foe Aleksei Navalny and deep-rooted government corruption.

    Tens of thousands of people took to the streets in Moscow, St. Petersburg, and other cities across the country on January 23 in Russia’s biggest anti-government demonstrations in years.

    The independent political watchdog OVD-Info reported that more than 3,700 people were detained during the largely peaceful protests, which the authorities had refused to sanction, often citing restrictions imposed due to the coronavirus pandemic.

    Russia’s ombudswoman for children’s issues, Anna Kuznetsova, said that about 300 minors were among those detained, including 70 in Moscow and 30 in St. Petersburg.

    HRW cited “numerous” reports of excessive use of force by police, noting that video footage showed officers “beating people with batons, pushing people to the ground, and kicking them.”

    TASS quoted a source in the law enforcement as saying 38 adults and five teenagers sought medical aid in Moscow alone after the protests.

    The independent Trade Union of Journalists and Media Workers said it reported more than 50 incidents of police assaulting journalists and detaining them in at least 17 cities.

    Russian authorities have also launched criminal cases against individuals accused of calling for mass riots, violence against police, and violating coronavirus-related public-health rules.

    In previous years, the Russian authorities retaliated against participants in mass protests with “showcase witch-hunt trials, which resulted in long prison terms,” according to HRW.

    “Time and time again, Russian authorities have suppressed free speech and peaceful protest through police brutality, violence, and mass arrests and January 23 was no exception,” Aitkhozhina said.

    She said the Russian authorities “understand their obligations to respect fundamental human rights and choose not just to ignore them but to trample all over them.”

    Navalny was detained a week ago upon returning to Russia after he flew back to Moscow from Germany, where he had been recovering from a near-fatal poisoning by a military-grade nerve agent in August.

    A court is expected to decide on February 2 whether to convert into prison time the suspended 3 1/2-year sentence that the opposition leader and anti-corruption crusader served in an embezzlement case that is widely considered trumped up and politically motivated.

    Navalny, whose suspended sentence ended on December 30, says it is a trumped-up case designed to silence him.

    EU foreign ministers are considering on January 25 their response to Navalny’s arrest and the police crackdown on protesters.

    Russia has rebuffed the global outrage over the police violence and the chorus of international calls calling for Navalny’s release.

    With reporting by TASS

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • U.S. Republican and Democratic lawmakers called for new sanctions against Moscow if the Kremlin moves to enforce stringent restrictions and punishing fines that threaten RFE/RL’s news operations in Russia.

    The letter, dated January 22, also called on President Joe Biden’s administration to do more to bolster RFE/RL’s operations in Belarus, which has been roiled by months of anti-government protests following Alyaksandr Lukashenka’s declaration of reelection in August.

    Opposition groups say that vote was rigged and many Western nations have refused to recognize Lukashenka’s declaration.

    Russian media regulator Roskomnadzor announced this month it was imposing hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines on RFE/RL’s operations in Russia, accusing it of failing to comply with new restrictions under the country’s “foreign agent” law.

    Among other things, the law requires certain news organizations that receive foreign funding to label content within Russia as being produced by a “foreign agent.”

    The law also puts RFE/RL journalists at risk for criminal prosecution.

    An independent nonprofit corporation that receives funding from the U.S. Congress, RFE/RL has not complied with the order. The mounting fines could potentially force the company to shutter its presence within Russia.

    Russian regulators have singled out RFE/RL, whose editorial independence is also enshrined in U.S. law, over other foreign news operations in Russia.

    “If Moscow proceeds with these actions, then we are prepared to work with your administration in considering using existing” U.S. laws to punish Russia, said the letter, which was signed by Representatives Greg Meeks and Michael McCaul, the top Democrat and top Republican on the House Foreign Affairs Committee. Three other lawmakers also signed.

    Those laws include the Magnitsky Act, the Global Magnitsky Act, and the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act — all of which have been used heavily over the past nine years to target Russian officials with visa bans and freezing assets.

    The Biden administration has signaled that it plans to take a new approach in U.S. relations with Russia, extending a major arms-control treaty while also voicing support for opposition groups, including anti-corruption crusader Aleksei Navalny.

    However, Russian officials have already made several aggressive moves, including accusing Washington of being behind the massive anti-government protests that swept across Russia on January 23 in support of Navalny.

    Navalny was jailed a week ago when he flew to Moscow after recuperating in Germany from a poisoning attack that he blames on Putin. The Kremlin has denied any involvement.

    Crisis In Belarus

    Read our coverage as Belarusians take to the streets to demand the resignation of President Alyaksandr Lukashenka and call for new elections after official results from the August 9 presidential poll gave Lukashenka a landslide victory.

    RFE/RL’s news operations “are a crucial tool to strengthen our allies’ democracies and prevent the democratic backsliding that opens the door for Russia, China, and other autocratic competitors to advance their own nefarious interests,” the letter said.

    Since early in Vladimir Putin’s presidency, the Kremlin has steadily tightened the screws on independent media. The country is ranked 149th out of 180 places in the World Press Freedom Index produced by Reporters Without Borders.

    Following the August presidential election, Belarusians took to the streets, accusing Lukashenka and government authorities of falsifying the vote. The protests, unprecedented in their size, have continued on a near-daily basis, despite a government crackdown.

    The election result has been rejected by many Western countries, who have called for a new vote.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • DUSHANBE — Mavjuda, a Tajik single mother in her 30s, makes her living by finding customers for a group of sex workers in the Tajik capital — even though pimping and prostitution are banned in the country.

    Mavjuda, who doesn’t want her full name published, may soon risk losing her children in order to keep them fed.

    Tajikistan’s parliament is set to amend the country’s Family Law in a way that would deprive convicted pimps and brothel owners of parental rights — with the state taking away any underage children they have.

    The bill is widely expected to be approved. Lawmakers and supporters of the legislation say it is aimed at tackling prostitution and protecting children. But critics say the best way to reduce prostitution and protect families is to create alternative jobs for women so they do not have to resort to working in the illegal sex industry.

    Many woman involved in the business say they became sex workers because of the extreme poverty they face in Tajikistan, one of the poorest countries in Central Asia.

    Mavjuda says she and the sex workers close to her have heard about the parliament debate over the proposed legislation. She told RFE/RL that women she knows are terrified at the prospect of being forced to hand their children over to the state.

    “Why do [the authorities] think taking away our children will solve anything?" asks Mavjuda, who finds clients for sex workers under her care.

    “Why do [the authorities] think taking away our children will solve anything?” asks Mavjuda, who finds clients for sex workers under her care.

    Mavjuda is the only income earner in her family. She says terminating parental rights would only add to the ordeals of the impoverished and cause further anguish in their “already miserable lives.”

    She said passage of the bill will not help anyone and will not bring an end in Tajikistan to what is known as the world’s oldest profession.

    “Why do [the authorities] think taking away our children will solve anything? [If they care about us], they should help us find jobs so we can work and provide better lives for our kids,” Mavjuda said.

    The drafting of the law comes after reports that police raids in Dushanbe and other cities have uncovered brothels. Under Tajik law, running a brothel or being involved in the procurement of hired sex is a felony that carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison. Repeat offenders face up to eight years in prison.

    Most of these women have at least one or two children for whom they are the only caregivers. Inevitably, what they do affects the minors. When the women are busy at work at night, the children are at home alone.”

    Prostitution is considered a misdemeanor in Tajikistan, punishable by fines of up to $200. Repeat offenders face higher fines or up to 15 days in detention.

    Sex workers often keep the source of their income secret from their relatives, fearing strong stigmas attached to prostitution in the predominantly Muslim society.

    Tajikistan’s State Committee for Women and Family Affairs has been involved in drafting the bill. Committee members say they believe the threat of taking away the custody of children would force people to think twice before getting involved in the risky business.

    Committee member Obidjon Sharipov told RFE/RL that the amendments to the existing Family Law would also protect the mental and physical well-being of the children.

    “Most of these women have at least one or two children for whom they are the only caregivers,” Sharipov said. “Inevitably, what they do affects the minors. When the women are busy at work at night, the children are at home alone.”

    Government officials and women’s groups say they conduct awareness campaigns that include so-called “morality lessons” for sex workers, trying to convince them to give up the occupation.

    The lessons involve lectures by doctors, law enforcement officials, and local community leaders who warn about the dangers of being involved in prostitution — such as the risk of becoming infected with sexually transmitted diseases or of falling victim to violence and human trafficking.

    Where would I find the money to pay rent and feed my kids?”

    Some sex workers accuse police of extorting money from prostitutes during raids or beating and insulting them while in custody. Authorities deny the allegations.

    “We get beaten up by clients, too. [If we call police, they] come and just write down our complaints, and that’s it,” says Zarina, a 21-year-old sex worker from Dushanbe.

    Zarina is the mother of two children who depend on her income. Zarina says she has been involved in prostitution since the age of 16. In recent years, Mavjuda has been helping her to find paying clients.

    Zarina fears that if the Family Law is amended in a way that forces Mavjuda to give up pimping, she would struggle to find her own customers and lose her only source of income.

    “Where would I find the money to pay rent and feed my kids?” Zarina asks, noting that she hasn’t completed her education and has no practical jobs skills or legal employment experience.

    Zarina also says she would gladly give up prostitution if there was another way for her to put food on the table for her children and pay the rent to keep a roof over their heads.

    Written by Farangis Najibullah in Prague with reporting from Dushanbe by RFE/RL Tajik Service correspondents Shahlo Abdulloh and Sarvinoz Ruhulloh

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • “Putin’s a thief!”

    The chant rang out in cities across Russia on January 23, as crowds took to the streets from Vladivostok in the Far East to Kaliningrad on the Baltic Sea and were met with a forceful police crackdown as opposition leader Aleksei Navalny’s showdown with the Kremlin entered a new phase.

    The last time Russia saw a day of rallies with such geographic scope was in March 2017, after Navalny released a video alleging corruption by then-Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev. This time, an immediate catalyst appeared to be a video report targeting the wealth of President Vladimir Putin himself.

    The nationwide demonstrations were initiated by the Kremlin’s most vocal critic, who languishes in jail, and staged under the slogan “Free Navalny!” But analysts say that the “Palace for Putin” investigation has combined with anger over Navalny’s jailing in a way that may reorient the political balance in Russia going forward.

    “There are two different motives for the protesters, but they are converging,” political analyst Abbas Gallyamov told RFE/RL. “Navalny is becoming synonymous with the fight against corruption.”

    Navalny returned to Russia on January 17 after five months in Germany recovering from the effects of a nerve-agent poisoning he blames on Putin, apparently banking on enough popular support to help him escape a long prison sentence threatened by the authorities – and mount a robust challenge to Putin’s power.

    The following day, he was jailed for a month pending a court hearing on parole violation charges that could land him behind bars for 3 1/2 years. Before he was led away, he called on Russians to hit the streets in a huge show of solidarity.

    In the video report released the next day – which has now been seen more than 70 million times on YouTube — he told his viewers that Putin and his associates “will keep stealing more and more until they bankrupt the whole country.”

    Revealing what the investigative report says is a $1.36 billion palace on the Black Sea that ultimately belongs to Putin, Navalny said: “Russia sells huge amounts of oil, gas, metals, fertilizer, and timber — but people’s incomes keep falling and falling, because Putin has his palace.”

    Russians responded in droves on January 23, protesting in at least 60 cities and braving winter temperatures that plunged as low as minus 52 degrees Celsius in Yakutsk, Siberia. Many held placards and signs citing the “Palace For Putin” investigation and denouncing official corruption.

    Police reacted with force, wading into peaceful protests, wielding batons and shields to disperse crowds, and filling riot vans with activists — including Navalny’s wife, Yulia Navalnaya, who had returned with him to Moscow from Germany. By late evening in Moscow, more than 3,400 people had been detained across the country, according to the OVD-Info protest monitor group.

    Russian state TV largely ignored the protests, but pro-government online streams baselessly accused Navalny of brainwashing Russia’s youth into dissent, a line often advanced by the authorities in attempts to discredit the opposition movement.

    “It’s not their own kids that they’re bringing out,” a guest on an online chat show run by the state-owned RT channel said about Navalny and his allies. “Navalny’s kids aren’t even in Russia!”

    But evidence of mass teenage participation appeared slim. In Moscow, an estimated 40,000 people came to a protest in central Pushkin Square, with few minors visible in the crowd. A 14-year-old boy who told a reporter he had come “to have a look” was later roughly detained by police amid cries of, “He’s just a child!”

    Navalny’s call for a protest in the midst of winter and the COVID-19 pandemic was seen as a gamble and a test of his ability to mount significant support for a new push against Putin, who has been in power for two decades and last year, in a referendum lambasted by critics, secured the right to run for reelection in 2024 and again in 2030.

    It was not immediately clear whether the sizable, widespread protests would result in Navalny avoiding a lengthy prison sentence. In 2013, large rallies in his support outside the Kremlin and other Moscow landmarks were credited with getting his five-year prison sentence suspended.

    “If protests on January 23 don’t bring about an immediate result — the release of Aleksei Navalny — then such events will happen again and again,” Navalny aide Leonid Volkov told Current Time, the Russian-language network run by RFE/RL in cooperation with VOA.

    IN PHOTOS: Navalny Supporters Brave Police Crackdown To Demand His Release

    IN PHOTOS: Navalny Supporters Brave Police Crackdown To Demand His Release Photo Gallery:

    IN PHOTOS: Navalny Supporters Brave Police Crackdown To Demand His Release

    Thousands of demonstrators were braving brutally cold weather and threats of police crackdowns across Russia on January 23 to call for the release of opposition politician Aleksei Navalny, a Kremlin critic jailed last week upon returning to Moscow after medical treatment in Germany for poisoning.

    The future of Russia’s embattled opposition movement also remains uncertain, but the size of the protests — even in the face of a concerted weeklong crackdown aimed at thwarting them — suggests that a substantial number of Russians may be determined to keep up the pressure.

    Tatyana Stanovaya, a political analyst, said that the Russian authorities “made two critical mistakes — Navalny’s poisoning and his arrest,” suggesting that instead of sidelining him, the Kremlin has only strengthened his base.

    “The results of many, many years of painstaking work by the Kremlin to push the real opposition” to the political margins “were ceremoniously buried today in a single day,” Stanovaya wrote on Telegram.

    The harsh police response and high number of arrests also point to what could be a bitter and protracted standoff if the rallies persist in the weeks ahead, especially with potentially pivotal parliamentary elections due to be held in September.

    Inside 'Putin's Palace'

    Inside 'Putin's Palace' Photo Gallery:

    Inside ‘Putin’s Palace’

    Images made by Aleksei Navalny’s anti-corruption team reveal the astonishing scale and luxury of a property on Russia’s Black Sea coast purportedly used by Vladimir Putin as his personal “palace.”

    In the meantime, Putin’s popularity has slipped amid the pandemic and anger over what many view as inadequate state support during Russia’s attendant economic crisis. The president has spent much of the time in recent months at his residence outside Moscow, making few public appearances.

    Neither has he commented publicly on Navalny’s report about the Black Sea palace, which his spokesman quickly dismissed as “lies.”

    “Navalny has taken over the initiative,” analyst Gallyamov said. “Now the state is defending itself.”

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Thousands of demonstrators were braving brutally cold weather and threats of police crackdowns across Russia on January 23 to call for the release of opposition politician Aleksei Navalny, a Kremlin critic jailed last weekend upon returning to Moscow after medical treatment in Germany for Novichok poisoning.

    The OVD-Info group, which monitors Russian police activity, reported at least 237 arrests across 30 cities ahead of the planned Moscow and St. Petersburg rallies — adding that authorities in Khabarovsk reportedly were beating detainees.

    Video posted on Twitter from Vladivostok showed police in riot gear charging at demonstrators and beating some with truncheons to disperse that gathering.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • ALMATY, Kazakhstan — Two ethnic Kazakhs from China’s northwestern province of Xinjiang with temporary refugee status in Kazakhstan have been violently attacked in the Central Asian country.

    Bekzat Maqsutkhan of the Naghyz Atazhurt (Real Fatherland) human rights group told RFE/RL that, late on January 21, an unknown assailant attacked Qaisha Aqan near her house in Almaty, hitting her head at least twice with a heavy object before trying to suffocate her.

    “Qaisha says she lost consciousness and woke up some time later lying in the snow. She was then able to call police and an ambulance,” Maqsutkhan said.

    Lawyer Gulmira Quatbekqyzy told RFE/RL that Aqan refused to stay in hospital fearing for her safety and is currently at home.

    On the same night, another ethnic Kazakh from Xinjiang, Murager Alimuly, was knifed and severely beaten in the village of Qoyandy near Nur-Sultan, the capital.

    Alimuly told RFE/RL that two unknown men suddenly stabbed him with a knife and hit his head and back with a metal bar as he was going home.

    “The knife did not penetrate deep into my body because it hit a power-bank gadget in my pocket, which saved me,” Alimuly said.

    Police in Almaty and Nur-Sultan told RFE/RL that probes have been launched into the two attacks.

    Aqan and Alimuly are two of several ethnic Kazakhs from Xinjiang residing in Kazakhstan. They had been convicted for illegally crossing the Chinese-Kazakh border in recent years, but received temporary refugee status in Kazakhstan in October.

    They have insisted that they fled China fearing that they would be placed in so-called reeducation camps for indigenous ethnic groups in Xinjiang.

    The U.S. State Department has said that as many as 2 million Uyghurs, Kazakhs, and members of Xinjiang’s other indigenous, mostly Muslim, ethnic groups have been taken to detention centers.

    China denies that the facilities are internment camps.

    Kazakhs are the second-largest Turkic-speaking indigenous community in Xinjiang after Uyghurs.

    The region is also home to ethnic Kyrgyz, Tajiks, and Hui, also known as Dungans.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • MINSK — A man has been hospitalized in grave condition after setting himself on fire in the central Independence Square in Minsk, where mass protests demanding the resignation of Alyaksandr Lukashenka have been under way since August.

    Video of the incident on January 22 showed a man engulfed in a fiery ball rolling on the ground for several seconds, with what appears to be a gas canister nearby.

    One video that captured the incident shows police officers trying to cover him with a blanket to extinguish the fire.

    The incident took place near the building that houses the government, parliament, Minsk city administration, and the City Council.

    Minsk city administration spokeswoman Natallya Hanusevich said in a statement that the incident was being investigated.

    Crisis In Belarus

    Read our coverage as Belarusians take to the streets to demand the resignation of President Alyaksandr Lukashenka and call for new elections after official results from the August 9 presidential poll gave Lukashenka a landslide victory.

    Interior Ministry spokeswoman Volha Chamadanava added in a statement that “at this point, it is not possible to give detailed information on the incident.”

    “The investigative group was dispatched to the site. As soon as we know all the circumstances around the incident, we will let the public know,” Chamadanava said.

    Health Ministry officials said that the man, whose identity was not disclosed, is unconscious and had burns over 50 percent of his body.

    Belarus has been gripped by a political crisis since August 9, when officials declared Alyaksandr Lukashenka, who has run the country with an iron fist since 1994, the winner of a presidential election.

    Opposition figures called the vote rigged, with thousands taking to the streets to protest on an almost daily basis.

    Lukashenka’s declaration of victory has not been recognized by Western nations, many of whom have slapped him and other Belarus officials with sanctions for their violent crackdown on the dissent.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A court in the southern Kazakh city of Taraz has ordered the immediate release of well-known civil rights activist Sanavar Zakirova and changed her prison sentence to a fine in a case that she says was politically motivated.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Lyubov Sobol, a lawyer for Russian opposition politician Aleksei Navalny, has been detained by police on a charge of calling for an unsanctioned rally in relation to a planned nationwide protest on January 23 in support of the jailed Kremlin critic.

    Sobol’s lawyer, Vladimir Voronin, tweeted on January 21 that police stopped his car and took his client to a police station to charge her there. Before that, three men had been at Sobol’s apartment and tried to hand her a written warning from the Moscow Prosecutor’s Office about the planned protest.

    Earlier in the day, a lawyer with Navalny’s Anti-Corruption Fund, Vladlen Los, who is Belarusian citizen, was briefly detained and informed that he must leave Russia before January 25.

    At a January 18 hearing that Navalny called a “mockery of justice,” a judge ruled to keep him incarcerated until February 15, by which time a different court is expected to decide whether to convert a suspended 3 1/2 year sentence he served in an embezzlement case, which he says is being trumped up into real jail time.

    His team subsequently called for nationwide protests on January 23.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A pan-European human rights watchdog has expressed concern after a Russian court handed a long prison sentence for hooliganism to a university mathematics student who says he was tortured while in custody.

    “The allegations we are hearing with regard to this case are certainly of concern, and we will continue to follow its development closely,” a spokeswoman at the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe’s (OSCE) Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) told RFE/RL on January 20, two days after 25-year-old Azat Miftakhov was sentenced to six years in prison.

    “ODIHR is continually following the human rights situation in all 57 countries of the OSCE region, and frequently raises issues with individual states,” Katya Andrusz said.

    The press service of the Council of Europe, the continent’s leading human rights organization, on Janaruy 19 said the organization was following the case “closely.”

    A court in the Russian capital on January 18 found Miftakhov, a postgraduate student at Moscow State University, guilty of being involved in an arson attack on the ruling United Russia party’s office in Moscow in 2018.

    Miftakhov has denied the charges, which his lawyers say stem from his anarchist beliefs and support for political prisoners.

    A prominent Russian human rights organization, Memorial, has declared Miftakhov a political prisoner.

    The student was arrested in early 2019 and accused of helping make an improvised bomb found in the city of Balashikha near Moscow.

    He was released several days after the initial charge failed to hold, but was rearrested immediately and charged with being involved in the attack on the United Russia office in January 2018.

    The Public Monitoring Commission, a human rights group, has said that Miftakhov’s body bore the signs of torture, which the student claimed were the result of investigators unsuccessfully attempting to force him to confess to the bomb-making charge.

    Others who were detained along with Miftakhov but later released also claim to have been beaten by police.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • CHITA, Russia — Prosecutors have asked a military court in Siberia to sentence Private Ramil Shamsutdinov to 25 years in prison for killing eight fellow servicemen in a rampage he says was brought on by the hazing he suffered while being initiated into the army.

    The Second Eastern Military District Court resumed the hearing into the high-profile case on January 19, where Shamsutdinov’s defense team reiterated that Shamsutdinov had gone on a shooting spree in October 2019, killing eight — including two high-ranking officers — in the town of Gorny in the Zabaikalye region after being tortured and beaten by other soldiers and officers during his induction into service.

    On December 28, a jury found Shamsutdinov guilty of murder and attempted murder, but decided that he deserves leniency, which according to Russian law means that he may be sentenced to a maximum of 13 years and four months in prison.

    The court’s officials told RFE/RL that Shamsutdinov’s sentence will be announced on January 21.

    The case shocked many in Russia and attracted the attention of rights activists after Shamsutdinov claimed that he committed the act while suffering a nervous breakdown caused by what he had endured.

    The Defense Ministry accepted at the time that Shamsutdinov “had a conflict” with one of the officers he killed. In March, Private Ruslan Mukhatov was found guilty of bullying Shamsutdinov and was handed a suspended two-year prison term.

    Deadly shootings at Russia’s military units as the result of widespread hazing have been a focus of human rights organizations for years.

    In November, a soldier at a military air base in the country’s western region of Voronezh shot an officer and two soldiers dead.

    In recent years, photos and video footage have been posted online by members of the Russian military that show the severe bullying of young recruits as they are inducted into the army.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A police officer in the Russian city of Samara has been placed under house arrest on suspicion of leaking data that may have helped the Bellingcat investigative group identify the alleged poisoners of Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny, the RBC business daily reports, citing its sources.

    Police officer Kirill Chuprov was detained in December and charged with abuse of power, according to an RBC report from January 19.

    Chuprov, who may face up to 10 years in prison if convicted, is accused of leaking confidential information from a database containing information about the movement of people across Russia to a third party, according to the RBC source, who is said to be close to the investigation, said.

    The leaked data was later used by investigative journalists who studied flights taken by agents of Russian’s Federal Security Service (FSB) who allegedly secretly followed Navalny for several years before he was poisoned with the Novichok nerve agent in Siberia in August last year.

    Bellingcat, a British-based open-source investigative group, and Russian media outlet The Insider published the investigation in December in cooperation with Der Spiegel and CNN.

    Citing “voluminous evidence in the form of telecoms and travel data,” the investigation, showed the August 2020 poisoning of the Kremlin critic appeared to have been in the works since at least early 2017.

    The European Union and Britain have imposed asset freezes and travel bans against six senior Russian officials believed to be responsible for the Navalny poisoning, as well as one entity involved in the program that has produced a group of military-grade nerve agents known as Novichok.

    Navalny, who was transported from Siberia to Germany for treatment after the incident, returned to Moscow on January 17. He was immediately arrested and sent to a pretrial detention center.

    On February 2, a court is expected to decide whether to convert into jail time a suspended 3 1/2 year sentence, which Navalny served in an embezzlement case that he says was trumped up.

    With reporting by RBC and Reuters

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Belarus has blasted the International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) for its decision to move the this year’s World Championships from Minsk due to safety and security concerns amid a violent government crackdown on protests over a disputed presidential election last year.

    The government’s organizing committee on January 19 called the IIHF’s decision, which is a blow to strongman Alyaksandr Lukashenka, “unreasonable,” while the head of the Belarus Ice Hockey Federation Dzmitry Baskau said it was “deplorable” that the Zurich-based governing body changed its mind on holding the tournament this spring in the capital.

    “[The IIHF’s] decision creates a precedent where sports tournaments that are supposed to unite countries and peoples, promote peace and unity in the spirit of the Olympic principles, can turn into a tool of discord and pressure to please the interests of politicians,” the Belarusian committee’s statement said.

    The IIHF’s announcement on January 18 came amid mounting pressure from European countries and sponsors for Belarus to be stripped of its role as co-host of the tournament in May-June with Latvia because of the postelection crackdown.

    Lukashenka has faced ongoing protests since a disputed August 9 presidential election, which the opposition says was rigged, handed him a sixth presidential term.

    The European Union and the United States have declined to recognize Lukashenka’s reelection and have imposed sanctions in connection with the crackdown on protesters.

    Several prominent Belarusian athletes have been handed jail terms of 10 to 15 days for their open support of the ongoing protests, demanding Lukashenka’s resignation.

    Nearly 350 Belarusian athletes and other members of the sports community threw down the gauntlet to Lukashenka by signing an open letter calling for the presidential election to be annulled and for all “political prisoners” and those detained during mass demonstrations that followed to be released.

    “It is a very regrettable thing to have to remove the Minsk/Riga co-hosting bid,” IIHF President Rene Fasel said in the announcement of the decision.

    “During this process, we had tried to promote that the World Championship could be used as a tool for reconciliation to help calm the socio-political issues happening in the Belarus and find a positive way forward…And while the Council feels that the World Championship should not be used for political promotion by any side, it has acknowledged that hosting this event in Minsk would not be appropriate when there are bigger issues to deal with and the safety and security of teams, spectators, and officials to prioritize.”

    Losing the chance to co-host the tournament is also a further blow to Lukashenka, who has cultivated an image as a jock, regularly taking to the ice to play hockey, his favorite sporting pastime.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Tens of thousands of ethnic Kazakhs in China’s Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region have been sent to “reeducation camps” along with hundreds of thousands of others from that western province after being rounded up by China because they are Muslims.

    Serikzhan Bilash is one of the people who helped bring this great injustice to light by exposing the suffering of ethnic Kazakhs at the camps in Xinjiang.

    An ethnic Kazakh from Xinjiang who moved to neighboring Kazakhstan in 2000, Bilash received Kazakh citizenship in 2011 under the “oralman” program, which was designed in 1991 to entice ethnic Kazakhs abroad to resettle in sparsely inhabited Kazakhstan.

    In 2017, Bilash founded the Atajurt Eriktileri (Volunteers of the Fatherland) organization to keep track of ethnic Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, and Uyghurs in Xinjiang as Beijing began implementing its latest and by far harshest campaign against perceived separatists, who were overwhelmingly Chinese Muslims.

    But China is a major investor in and trade partner of Kazakhstan.

    That brought the 46-year-old Bilash and his work into conflict with Kazakh authorities, and he was arrested and charged with inciting ethnic hatred in March 2019.

    But amid an international outcry and quite a lot of rumbling from inside Kazakhstan — where many people wondered why the government would try to silence someone defending ethnic Kazakhs against Chinese repression — Bilash was convicted in August 2019 but given a fine and released from custody in exchange for promising to cease his activism for seven years.

    But the pressure on Bilash, his family, and associates was massive and did not stop.

    So, in late summer 2020, Bilash and his family began their journey to Turkey, where they have been since September 10.

    He recently spoke with RFE/RL’s Kazakh Service, known locally as Azattyq, to explain why he chose to leave.

    “In April 2020, two charges were filed against me [in Kazakhstan] — desecration of the state flag and inciting hatred,” he said.

    Bilash attempted to register Atajurt Eriktileri in Kazakhstan, but after his court case in 2019, Kazakh authorities registered another group called Atajurt Eriktileri, which was a phony splinter group made up of members who took a soft stance against China.

    Bilash then founded a group called Naghyz (the Real) Atajurt.

    Bilash told Azattyq that the desecration of the state flag charge stems from comments he made about a court case involving Saltanat Kusmankyzy, a Kazakh woman working for a Chinese company in Kazakhstan who was convicted of embezzlement in January 2020 and sentenced to eight years in prison.

    Lawyer Ayman Umarova (left) with Serikzhan Bilash (file photo)

    Lawyer Ayman Umarova (left) with Serikzhan Bilash (file photo)

    Kusmankyzy’s lawyer Ayman Umarova, who is also one of Bilash’s lawyers, said the court refused to accept her client’s evidence, which would have cleared her of the charge.

    Bilash said his comments about Kusmankyzy’s case were taken out of context and bizarrely presented as disrespecting the Kazakh flag.

    Bilash said police conducted a linguistic analysis of the comments that showed nothing Bilash said amounted to denigrating the flag.

    ‘A Heavy Blow’

    Bilash said one of the people behind the inciting hatred charge was Erbol Dauletbek, the leader of the Atajurt Eriktileri group registered instead of Bilash’s group. Bilash said Dauletbek is trying to gain the rights to Bilash’s Atajurt Kazakh Human Rights channel on YouTube.

    RFE/RL’s Kazakh Service, known locally as Azattyq, asked Dauletbek about the claim but he denied filing any legal complaints against Bilash.

    Keeping the YouTube channel is part of the reason Bilash went to Turkey. Bilash officially registered the popular channel in 2013.

    “There were not any mass arrests in China then…and there was not even an organization called Atajurt,” Bilash said.

    He added that Kazakh police started coming to the apartment of Galym Rakizhan, the editor of the video for the Atajurt YouTube channel, and threatened the owner, who finally told Rakizhan he must leave despite having lived there for many years.

    Bilash then signed over the YouTube channel to Turkish citizen Babisalem Okitan, who is also a member of Naghyz Atajurt and now in charge of programming for the channel.

    Bilash said he has no plans to seek asylum in Turkey and intends to return to Kazakhstan. But he noted that cannot happen until he is cleared of charges there and the pressure against him, his family, and his organization ceases.

    “On August 18, 2020, a court ruled that I was involved with the activities of an unregistered illegal organization and was fined…[the equivalent of $333]. Several members of Naghyz Atajurt Eriktileri were also fined,” he said. “That was a heavy blow for us.”

    “Any time I drove, [the police] stopped me without fail,” Bilash said. “Day and night there are people and vehicles outside my house. My relatives and my wife’s relatives have all been questioned.”

    ‘Branded A Terrorist’

    Bilash said he was also put on a blacklist in Kazakhstan.

    Bilash said Kazakh authorities have branded him a terrorist and, when his mother died and he went to the notary to sign over her property to his father, he was told it was not possible.

    “It turns out that on their network I was shown to be a terrorist, I have a screenshot of it… from the computer at the notary public,” Bilash explained.

    He added that his bank accounts in Kazakhstan have been frozen and his car was impounded.

    Bilash also recounted seven meetings he had in 2019 while he was under house arrest in Nur-Sultan and Almaty with a person named Maksat Iskakov, a representative that Bilash said was sent by President Qasym-Zhomart Toqaev.

    According to Bilash, at one of those meetings, Iskakov told him, “In September [2019], Mr. Toqaev is going to China and your sentence [and conviction] will be a present to the Chinese president.”

    Iskakov advised him to cooperate with Kazakh officials and agree to the deal whereby he would be fined and cease his activism for seven years.

    “My goals were not to challenge Kazakh authorities, I wanted to defend the rights of Kazakhs and other Turkic-speaking peoples who were abused in China,” Bilash said in explaining why he agreed to the deal.

    Bilash also assured: “I am not a dangerous person to the authorities of Kazakhstan, I am not an opposition figure, not an opponent.”

    Bilash said he hoped Turkish authorities will register Naghyz Atajurt. If that happens, Bilash said the group will then seek recognition as a human rights defender from international organizations.

    In the meantime, Bilash has been trying to help five other Kazakhs who recently illegally crossed from Xinjiang into Kazakhstan to obtain Turkish citizenship.

    Azattyq sent a copy of Bilash’s interview to the Kazakh Foreign Ministry and the presidential administration seeking comment but there had been no response as of the time this report was issued.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A 71-year-old Turkmen journalist has been nominated among three finalists for a prestigious human rights award for her reports from Turkmenistan, one of the most repressive countries in the world.

    The Martin Ennals Award for Human Rights Defenders in Geneva said on January 18 that Soltan Achilova “documents the human rights abuses and social issues affecting the Turkmen people in their daily lives.”

    The jury composed of 10 activist groups, including Amnesty International, recognized Achilova’s work in a country where “freedom of speech is inexistent and independent journalists work at their own peril.”

    “Despite the repressive environment and personal hardships, she is one of the very few reporters in the country daring to sign independent articles,” the statement said.

    Based in Ashgabat, Achilova is a contributor to the Vienna-based independent news website Khronika Turkmenistana (Chronicles of Turkmenistan), which focuses on news and developments in Turkmenistan.

    She has in the past worked as a reporter for RFE/RL’s Turkmen Service.

    Turkmen authorities, who don’t tolerate an independent press, have targeted the journalist for her work.

    Achilova has been detained by police and physically assaulted by officers, thugs, and other unidentified assailants, while her relatives had also come under pressure by the authorities.

    The two other nominees for the Martin Ennals Award are leading Saudi advocate for women’s rights Loujain Al-Hathloul and Chinese lawyer and human rights activist Yu Wensheng. Both of them are currently in jail.

    The statement said that the award ceremony “will celebrate their courage” during an online event co-hosted by the city of Geneva on February 11.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • For more than a decade, Aleksei Navalny has been one of President Vladimir Putin’s most outspoken and influential critics in Russia, investigating high-level corruption, organizing protests, and traveling across the country to back opposition candidates in regional elections and nurture his network of political activists.

    Navalny’s arrest has failed to rouse the population as a whole.”

    Authorities have responded with a campaign of near-constant harassment, jailing the Kremlin critic almost a dozen times since 2011, repeatedly raiding the offices of his Anti-Corruption Foundation, and — Navalny asserts — staging an attempted assassination by means of poisoning that led to his extended convalescence in Germany since August.

    When he announced he would return to Russia on January 17, authorities made clear their intention to jail the Kremlin critic. That evening, Navalny was detained at the airport after arrival and taken to a police station outside Moscow, where he appeared before an improvised courtroom and a state prosecutor asked the judge to jail him pending a separate hearing on whether he violated the terms of his earlier parole.

    But striking footage from the previous evening continued to circulate online, showing riot police dispersing and detaining Navalny supporters as they awaited his expected arrival at Moscow’s Vnukovo airport, and cars being blocked from exiting the area once news emerged that his flight was being rerouted to another airport, Sheremetyevo.

    [The Kremlin] fears the man with no name.”

    The Kremlin has denied involvement in the August poisoning —despite evidence from open-source investigations that it was carried out by the Federal Security Service (FSB) — and has gone out of its way to downplay Navalny’s significance as a politician, with Putin calling him “the Berlin patient” and “the man in question” to avoid even uttering his name. But the scenes sparked by Navalny’s repatriation, analysts say, expose the very real challenge he presents for the Kremlin and the reasons why authorities have moved so fast to jail him.

    “The Kremlin has shown that for all its pretense of disinterest, it fears the man with no name,” Russia expert Mark Galeotti wrote in a column.

    Navalny has made a name for himself despite facing what is arguably the Russian state’s most powerful political weapon: a network of state-controlled TV channels that are well-funded, often take cues directly from the Kremlin, and have baselessly painted him as a Western agent. A September poll by the independent Levada Center found that a majority of Russians see his poisoning as a publicity stunt, with only 15 percent blaming the Kremlin, despite the evidence of its complicity.

    Police detain participants of a protest in support of Navalny in St.Petersburg on January 18.

    Police detain participants of a protest in support of Navalny in St.Petersburg on January 18.

    Nevertheless, millions have watched his video investigations alleging corruption among associates of Putin, and thousands across the country have heeded his call to attend anti-government protests several times in recent years. But after his poisoning, few Russians took to the streets in protest. And restrictions associated with the coronavirus pandemic and an accelerating clampdown on dissent in Russia have contributed to a widespread sense, surveys show, that demonstrating against injustice is too often a futile activity.

    “Navalny’s arrest has failed to rouse the population as a whole,” wrote political analyst Vladislav Inozemtsev. “That’s sad, but you can’t ignore it.”

    On January 18, at Navalny’s hearing outside Moscow, the judge overseeing proceedings inside the police station holding the opposition leader returned after more than 45 minutes to deliver her ruling. She ordered Navalny jailed for 30 days, long past an expected January 29 hearing regarding his alleged parole violation. Lawyers say the outcome of that process could be a 3 1/2 -year prison sentence, and Navalny could be hit with additional charges that carry a sentence of up to 10 years.

    Before being led away, Navalny addressed Russians with a call for mass protests across the country on January 23 — throwing down the gauntlet both to a Kremlin reluctant to acknowledge his influence and to a population that he hopes will brave the winter cold, and a likely police crackdown, to demand his freedom.

    “Don’t be scared,” Navalny said in a video posted from the makeshift courtroom, sitting against the backdrop of a folded Russian flag. “Take to the streets.”

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • A media watchdog has called on Turkey to halt the expulsion of an Iranian journalist sentenced to prison for alleged activities against the regime after criticizing Tehran’s response to the coronavirus pandemic.

    The U.S-based Committee To Protect Journalists (CPJ) said in a statement on January 18 that Mohammad Mosaed contacted the group a day earlier saying he had been detained by Turkish border police after crossing into Turkey from Iran at the eastern border city of Van.

    Mosaed told the CPJ that he fled to Turkey after being summoned by Iranian authorities to begin serving his prison sentence in two days’ time.

    He said the Turkish police took him to hospital for medical treatment, and told him he would soon be handed back to Iranian border guards.

    Mosaed was sentenced in August by an Iranian court to four years and nine months in prison on charges of “colluding against national security” and “spreading propaganda against the system” after posting a tweet critical of the government’s tackling of the outbreak.

    The CPJ at the time described the ruling as a further attempt by Iranian authorities to try to “suppress the truth.”

    Mosaed was first detained in November 2019 in connection with messages he had posted on social media during an Internet shutdown implemented by the government amid widespread protests over high gas prices.

    He was honored with the CPJ’s 2020 International Press Freedom Award in November.

    “We believe that Mohammad Mosaed has a well-founded fear of persecution should he be returned to Iran,” said CPJ Middle East and North Africa Coordinator Sherif Mansour said in the statement.

    “We urge Turkish authorities to respect their obligations under international law; to refrain from deporting Mosaed; to consider any request for political asylum that Mosaed may make; and to assure Mosaed’s rights are protected through due process of law.”

    CPJ said phone messages to the office of the Turkish province of Van, where Mosaed is being detained, were not immediately returned.

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.

  • Kremlin critic Aleksei Navalny appeared at a hearing on January 18, the day after he was detained at a Moscow airport upon his arrival from Germany. He was being treated in Berlin after being poisoned in Russia in August. His spokeswoman posted a video of Navalny speaking at the hearing, which he labeled “the highest degree of lawlessness.”

    This post was originally published on Radio Free.