Trigger warning: Suicide
A video of a person falling off an electricity tower is being circulated on social media with the claim that the man climbed up the transmission tower to offer namaz with the belief that the height would take him closer to Allah.
Twitter Blue user Dr Deepak Deshpande (@ddtimes) shared the said video on June 9 with a caption in Hindi that says: “After efficiently reciting Nawaz on bus, train, plane, road etc., this Maulana used to climb on the pole to offer namaz, because of the height he thought he could be closer to the almighty…so almighty directly called him above… to show heaven. Pray wisdom prevails. Prayers are divine.” (Archive)
बस, ट्रेन, प्लेन रोड आदि पर कुशलतापूर्वक नवाज़ पढ़ने के बाद, ये मौलाना नमाज़ पढ़ने के लिए खंभे पे चढ़ा था, जहां से Height पर होने की वजह से, ऊपरवाले के ज्यादा करीब हो जाऐ …इसलिए ऊपरवाले ने वहां सीधा ऊपर से ही ऊपर बुला लिया… जन्नत दिखाने के लिए. Pray wisdom prevails.… pic.twitter.com/ulqnCIIc2m
— Dr Deepak Deshpande (@ddtimes) June 9, 2023
Another Twitter user Manoj Srivastava (@ManojSr60583090) shared the same video on June 6 with a caption in Hindi that can be translated as: “This madrassa-stamped guy climbed a tower to offer namaz. Maulvi Madani of Deoband told this in a speech that the higher the height you pray from, the sooner God will listen to you. I wish even the Mullahs who offer morning Azaan would understand this”. The tweet has been retweeted over 200 times. (Archive)
*यह मदरसा छाप नमाज़ पढ़ने के लिये खंभे पे चढ़ा था*
*देवबंद के मौलवी मदनी ने इसे तकरीर में बताया*
*जितना उंचाइ से नमाज पड़ोगे खुदा उतनी जल्दी सुनेगा*
*काश ये बात सुबह सुबह अज़ान देने वाले मुल्ले भी समझ जातै* pic.twitter.com/aLoz0SQmdo
— Manoj Srivastava (@ManojSr60583090) June 6, 2023
Several other social media users including @MithilaWaala, @Devil_Return72 shared the video with similar claims. Some can be found below.
Click to view slideshow.Fact Check
We broke down the video with the help of InVid software into several keyframes and ran a reverse image search on some of them. This led us to a few tweets from 2018 which carried the same video. To begin with, this shows that the video is old. (Examples 1, 2)
Click to view slideshow.We also came across a report in Spanish by Telemundo, an American Spanish-language terrestrial television network, from May 16, 2018. The headline of the report can be translated as: “Moment at which a young man dies after being electrocuted by an electrical tower (VIDEO)”. As per the report, the incident happened in Barranquilla, Colombia. The 20-year-old man had climbed 50 metres to reach the top of the tower when he lost his balance and touched the wires and ended up being electrocuted.
Taking a hint from the above information we ran a relevant keyword search and found more news reports from 2018.
According to a report by Metro UK, the man’s name was Victor Jose Arroyo Gonzalez. He was hearing-impaired and suicidal. The report says that he climbed up the tower with the intention of jumping off from the height, but passers by and police talked him out of it and he changed his mind. While trying to climb down the tower he touched a live wire and was electrocuted.
Therefore, the claims that the man seen in the video climbed up the transmission tower to offer namaz are false. It is an incident from 2018 in Columbia when 20-year-old Victor Jose Arroyo Gonzalez climbed up the tower with the intention of suicide but later changed his mind and met with this accident while trying to climb back down the tower.
It is pertinent to note that Twitter user Amitabh Chaudhary (@MithilaWaala) shares misinformation on social media frequently. In the past one week, Alt News has found him sharing false information four times, all of them communal in nature. The related fact checks can be read here.
The post Namaz atop electricity tower? Old video from Colombia falsely shared mocking Muslims appeared first on Alt News.
This content originally appeared on Alt News and was authored by Oishani Bhattacharya.
This post was originally published on Radio Free.
